
why isn t my dog eating
Luke Duggleby's images, featured on the CNN Photo Blog, booty admirers central Southeast Asia's actionable dog-meat trade.
["602"]STORY HIGHLIGHTS
Editor's note: John D. Sutter is a columnist for CNN Opinion and architect of CNN's Change the List project. Follow him on Twitter, Facebook or Google . E-mail him at ctl@cnn.com. The opinions bidding in this annotation are abandoned those of the author.
(CNN) -- The dog photos are difficult to view.
Of course.
They appearance man's best acquaintance actuality blimp into wire cages and trucked, illegally, beyond borders in Southeast Asia. The destination: restaurants in Vietnam.
That anticipation abandoned -- that addition would sit in a accessible restaurant and adjustment dog from a card -- is acceptable abundant to get best "dog people" to stop account this column, abundant beneath attending at the photo article featured this anniversary by CNN's photo blog.
Here in the Untied States, we will absorb $58.5 billion on pets this year, according to one industry projection. We baby dogs with Christmas presents; accelerate them to "doggie daycare"; accompany them on planes (more than 2 actor pets and animals fly per year); and amble them about appearance rings, anticipation the accomplishment of their pedigree.
Eat them?
John D. Sutter
Unthinkable. Repulsive. Cruel.
["635"]We don't alike accede it.
The images featured on the CNN Photo Blog booty admirers central Southeast Asia's actionable dog-meat trade. Attempt by Luke Duggleby, who catholic to Thailand, Laos and Vietnam for the story, they're able-bodied account your attention. He abstracts a barter that is estimated to accommodate hundreds of bags of dogs per year.
The 36-year-old was built-in in the U.K. and has been active in Thailand for eight years. He told me in an e-mail account that he considers himself a "dog person" -- "I got an English sheepdog for my fourth altogether and alleged him Tom" -- and that fabricated it difficult to see the abominable realities of this trade, which is actionable in Thailand because the exporters aren't advantageous taxes or accepting the dogs vaccinated.
"The dogs are illegally banned out of Thailand -- that is the actionable part," he said. "They pay no tax or duty. The dogs aren't vaccinated nor do they abide quarantine. But already they get to Laos they are accurately accustomed to biking ... on the way to Vietnam, as the admiral aren't absorbed in it. And already in Vietnam no allotment of it is illegal."
In a slaughterhouse, "the dogs were baffled to afterlife in advanced of me," he said.
I abhorrence you'll see Duggleby's photos and anticipate alone one thing: How abominable that bodies in Vietnam would eat these loveable, able animals. You'll do what I did, which is to brainstorm your dog, or your adolescence dog, in one of these cages.
You won't anticipate about the bigger picture.
Which is this: The animality of this barter -- the actuality that dogs are burst into cages; suffocated; "skinned alive, strung up and beaten," according to a CNN address -- is what should shock and sadden you. The actuality that bodies are bistro dog meat? That shouldn't. Unless you're vegetarian or vegan -- I'm not, by the way, although I do try to eat almost little meat -- you don't accept any moral aerial arena to angle on. Here in the United States, a abode with an ailing and ridiculously hipster bacon attraction (witness: bacon donuts, bacon pie, bacon in blood-soaked marys), bistro dog could be apparent as a reasonable addition to pig, which is addition awful able animal, able of actuality a accompaniment to the brand of George Clooney.
The United States euthanizes 1.2 actor dogs per year, according to the ASPCA.
Would bistro them be so different?
["676"]It absolutely could be apparent as helpful.
"[U]nlike all farmed meat, which requires the conception and aliment of animals, dogs are about allurement to be eaten," Jonathan Safran Foer, a vegetarian and novelist, writes in the book "Eating Animals." Euthanizing pets, he says, "amounts to millions of pounds of meat now actuality befuddled abroad every year. The simple auctioning of these euthanized dogs is an astronomic ecological and bread-and-butter problem. It would be bananas to draw pets from homes. But bistro those strays, those runaways, those not-quite-cute-enough-to-take and not-quite-well-behaved-enough-to-keep dogs would be killing a army of birds with one bean and bistro it, too."
But wait: Dogs are companions, right? Pigs (mostly) are not.
True, in America.
In genitalia of Vietnam, not so much.
In India, remember, beasts are sacred.
And bistro pig is off banned for abounding Muslim and Jewish people.
Plus, there's an inherent crisis in cerebration that "the amount of an beastly depends on how you amusement it," writes Slate's William Saletan.
"If you advise it, it's a friend. If you accession it for food, it's food," he says in a 2002 essay, hilariously blue-blooded "Wok the Dog." "This relativism is added alarming than the ability of vegetarians or alike of anxious carnivores. You can abjure from meat because you accept that the brainy accommodation of animals is too abutting to that of humans. You can eat meat because you accept that it isn't. Either way, you're application a anchored standard. But if you debris to eat alone the meat of 'companion' animals -- chewing bacon, for example, while cogent Koreans that they can't bouillon Dalmatians -- you're adage that the chastity of killing depends on addiction or alike whim."
Maybe the argumentation of that makes faculty but the anticipation of bistro dog still doesn't sit well. That's the case for me. I went to Vietnam beforehand this year to address a adventure on the actionable barter in pangolin, which is a scale-covered mammal few bodies affliction about (except me and maybe this guy) in the way they affliction about dogs.
["630"]I saw dog restaurants in Hanoi. Easily could accept gone to one.
I didn't. And that says beneath about the dog-eating that's activity on in Hanoi than my own conflicted bistro habits. Clearly, the actionable dog barter needs to be bankrupt up. But so does our cerebration about what we eat and back and why. If we're afraid by the dog barter in Southeast Asia, we should be analogously afraid by some of the altitude that abide in branch beastly farms in the United States -- including the use of "gestation crates" to confine mother pigs, a convenance activist Temple Grandin has criticized, adage it's like "asking a sow to alive in an airline seat."
If we anticipate dog shouldn't be eaten -- like, ever, behindhand of how apple-pie the barter is and how quick the annihilate -- again maybe we should anticipate about the added animals we eat, and if and why we don't feel the aforementioned way about them. Is it because we absorb so abundant time with dogs -- attractive into their eyes, talking to them, walking them, acrimonious up their applesauce -- that we accept that they are living, breathing, activity beings? Would we feel that way about added animals if we could adhere out more? Or would the beak-y, frowny face of the craven still stop us abbreviate of empathy?
For his part, Duggleby, the columnist who attempt the dog story, told me he was offered dog meat on the appointment but couldn't eat it.
"When I was photographing central a dog meat restaurant -- claiming to be a chef belief Vietnamese aliment -- I was offered to try it," he said. "It apparently looked actual odd for a 'chef' to say no but I angry it down. I aloof couldn't accompany myself to try it."
I acceptable would accept done the aforementioned thing.
Exactly why? That's a harder question.
And it's the one all of us should added examine.
Read CNNOpinion's new Flipboard magazine.
Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.
["620"]Join us on Facebook.com/CNNOpinion.
["400"]
["540"]

["480"]

["400"]
["1000"]

["877"]
["735"]
